First 'fully accurate' totally voice-controlled phone unveiled
You’d probably expect a groundbreaking mobile phone to be developed deep inside Nokia’s HQ or in a military bunker. However, a supposedly super-secure handset described as the world’s first truly hands-free mobile has, in fact, been designed on an industrial estate in Hereford, UK.
Can't see the video? Download Flash Player …
Seriously, I know the Reg is just pleased to pass on something pretending it to be news, but this is getting ridiculous. It's a lark, obviously. A "super-secret" factory filled with housewives and soldering irons, developing a state-of-the-art phone? Called the Zumba, which has a website. Called the Zumba Lumpa? Either the Reg is in on this hoax, or they've just proven that they have absolutely no editorial capacity. In which case, I'd like to apply for the job of senior editor please.
It was a funny report not really aimed at anouncing the phone but a bit of a fishing exercise for VC funding, the beeb fell for it hook line & sinker as a 'good news story' in times of the credit crunchy nut cornflake economic missmanagement meltdown. The phone mockup was a couple of bits of styrofoam, not even a half decent photoshop 3d render!
Why steve, well perhaps he'll licence the technology!
what the hell? if you've got the time to speak your voice message into the phone, then why don't you just call them and have a frikken conversation?
and how smart is the software really? can it tell that someone over the age of 20 is dictating a SMS and so dictate their message word for word, but if the voice is more youthful sounded, will it translate on the fly from "Hi, how are you, what's the latest news?" to "how R U? N E new bants? lolz raaarrrr kthxby" ?
"The technology is so top secret, I can't even give you a demonstration of how it works."
Yeah, right. Heard that before. If it works so well, they should be dying to show it in action, as doing so doesn't reveal any technical details about the implementation. This just indicates that it doesn't work as well as their PR would like you to believe.
"If you lose this phone, it's instantly useless to anyone else [blah blah] totally secure."
Yeah, right. How? 100% accurate voiceprint identification? I don't think so. If you have to authenticate yourself in some way, then it's not really any more secure than any existing phone that can be password locked. Indeed I'd be more worried about some website that's not under my control getting hacked than I would about someone going to the trouble of trying to decrypt data on my phone's internal storage.
Plus, this is a British company, and everyone knows we don't do consumer electronics innovation here any more, so this is pretty much guaranteed bullshit.
There's footage of people hand soldering components - considering the size of the device and earpiece I doubt it was made in that factory. Looks like a plastic mock-up to me.
Did you see the workers? cutting 2mm wire? Dont use that in any mobile phone I've owned! Soldering (dear Yanks the L is not silent!) by hand? not in my mobile they arn't!
The size of the track on that PCB was about 3 mm across This thing is sooo FAKE!
that the 1st guy from the company bears more than a passing resemblance to Anton Dubeck from that dancing show the wife watches, what does he know about website security?
On that subject if they have developed a 100% secure web site technology I would guess they could make more from that than any poxy phone?
Er, Wildfire, anyone? Before it canned by Orange? Apparently there were plans to expand into non-voice areas, such as reading out email and text, but the plug got pulled. It shouldn't have been too difficult to get her to take dictation and send it out as a text or email.
"If you loose this phone it is instantly useless to anyone else" -Thats right mate. It would probably be useless before I loose it. Because its not really a phone is it. Your just waving about a thin bit of plastic. I'd stick with your ejector seats. Good luck for the floatation.
First 'fully accurate' totally voice-controlled phone unveiled
You’d probably expect a groundbreaking mobile phone to be developed deep inside Nokia’s HQ or in a military bunker. However, a supposedly super-secure handset described as the world’s first truly hands-free mobile has, in fact, been designed on an industrial estate in Hereford, UK. Can't see the video? Download Flash Player …
This topic is closed for new posts.
Posted Friday 30th January 2009 13:41 GMT
Anonymous Coward
Should have checked your copy with Lewis first #
Developed in a secure location?
I think this town is pretty safe as far as the UK goes.
Stirling (sic) stuff.
Posted Friday 30th January 2009 13:41 GMT
Anonymous Coward
Vaporware alert #
"...that the company told the BBC is 100 per cent secure"
Oh what's that? You're 99% of the way to market and just need another £500k? Well, as you're so close...
Posted Friday 30th January 2009 13:41 GMT
OzBob
contextual problems with voice recognition,.... #
like when the guy in the automated house at a technology expo exclaimed "b*gger me"!
Posted Friday 30th January 2009 13:41 GMT
Buck Futter
Oh now, come on! #
Seriously, I know the Reg is just pleased to pass on something pretending it to be news, but this is getting ridiculous. It's a lark, obviously. A "super-secret" factory filled with housewives and soldering irons, developing a state-of-the-art phone? Called the Zumba, which has a website. Called the Zumba Lumpa? Either the Reg is in on this hoax, or they've just proven that they have absolutely no editorial capacity. In which case, I'd like to apply for the job of senior editor please.
Posted Friday 30th January 2009 13:41 GMT
Adrian Barnett
Terrible idea #
So now we are going to have to put up with kids all day shouting things like
"NEW TEXT RECIPIENTS SHAZZA BAZZA AND TEZZA". OH EMM GEE ELL OH ELL EXCLAMATION MARK SEE YOU LATER SEND TEXT"
Clever technology yes, I just feel it's going to be very, very annoying.
Posted Friday 30th January 2009 13:41 GMT
Joe K
"100 per cent secure" #
Instant fail. No such thing.
And what if you have a cold, or other kind of sore throat, are you completely fucked then?
Posted Friday 30th January 2009 13:41 GMT
Pink Duck
Erm... #
100% voice recognition accuracy?
100% secure?
I think not.
Posted Friday 30th January 2009 13:41 GMT
Anonymous Coward
100% secure.............. #
Danger Will Robinson........
Posted Friday 30th January 2009 13:41 GMT
Anonymous Coward
It made me chuckle #
It was a funny report not really aimed at anouncing the phone but a bit of a fishing exercise for VC funding, the beeb fell for it hook line & sinker as a 'good news story' in times of the credit crunchy nut cornflake economic missmanagement meltdown. The phone mockup was a couple of bits of styrofoam, not even a half decent photoshop 3d render!
Why steve, well perhaps he'll licence the technology!
Posted Friday 30th January 2009 13:41 GMT
jai
voice recognition txt msg? #
what the hell? if you've got the time to speak your voice message into the phone, then why don't you just call them and have a frikken conversation?
and how smart is the software really? can it tell that someone over the age of 20 is dictating a SMS and so dictate their message word for word, but if the voice is more youthful sounded, will it translate on the fly from "Hi, how are you, what's the latest news?" to "how R U? N E new bants? lolz raaarrrr kthxby" ?
Posted Friday 30th January 2009 13:41 GMT
Ash
Phone 100% Secure #
Website 30%
Posted Friday 30th January 2009 13:41 GMT
Dom
Vapourfone. #
My bet is that this is the first and last we'll hear of this. The Beeb can't show it working because it doesn't.
Posted Friday 30th January 2009 13:44 GMT
Steve Copley
Sniff, sniff, sniff... #
Ahhhhh... The smell of vapourware wafting across Herefordshire!
Posted Friday 30th January 2009 13:44 GMT
tony72
Angling for investment, much? #
"The technology is so top secret, I can't even give you a demonstration of how it works."
Yeah, right. Heard that before. If it works so well, they should be dying to show it in action, as doing so doesn't reveal any technical details about the implementation. This just indicates that it doesn't work as well as their PR would like you to believe.
"If you lose this phone, it's instantly useless to anyone else [blah blah] totally secure."
Yeah, right. How? 100% accurate voiceprint identification? I don't think so. If you have to authenticate yourself in some way, then it's not really any more secure than any existing phone that can be password locked. Indeed I'd be more worried about some website that's not under my control getting hacked than I would about someone going to the trouble of trying to decrypt data on my phone's internal storage.
Plus, this is a British company, and everyone knows we don't do consumer electronics innovation here any more, so this is pretty much guaranteed bullshit.
Posted Friday 30th January 2009 13:44 GMT
richard
oh dear #
the 'inventor' looks like yer typical mobile sales-clown. sorry, another gimmick that we'll never see again. back to the refineries, bbc.
Posted Friday 30th January 2009 13:44 GMT
jubtastic1
I can reveal the secret #
The speech recognition is provided by Umpa Lumpas in Zumba mission control.
Posted Friday 30th January 2009 13:44 GMT
Anonymous Coward
Psion #
I wonder if Psion Computers would be releasing products like this today if they'd survived?
Posted Friday 30th January 2009 13:44 GMT
Dazzz
Hmmm #
Bit light on facts that report wasnt it...
Posted Friday 30th January 2009 13:44 GMT
Skizz
Something fishy... #
There's footage of people hand soldering components - considering the size of the device and earpiece I doubt it was made in that factory. Looks like a plastic mock-up to me.
Posted Friday 30th January 2009 13:44 GMT
David Heys
So let's get this right... #
...that incredibly thin 'earpiece' has enough electronics to hold a speaker, microphone, transmitter/receiver and battery?
I had to check it wasn't April 1st.
Posted Friday 30th January 2009 13:44 GMT
Anonymous Coward
100% secure #
Anyone who claims 100% security immediately disqualifies themselves from being competent to discuss security.
Posted Friday 30th January 2009 15:32 GMT
Tony Barnes
lol #
Have to agree with lots of the comments above, stinks of BS to me!
Posted Friday 30th January 2009 15:32 GMT
Doug Southworth
Please... #
The only thing missing from that crack job of reporting was the tag line "Call now, and we will instantly double your order!"
Terrible.
Posted Friday 30th January 2009 15:32 GMT
Anonymous Coward
Dead Canary! #
VAPOUR ALERT!
100% secure = impossible
100% Fully working = erm No
Did you see the workers? cutting 2mm wire? Dont use that in any mobile phone I've owned! Soldering (dear Yanks the L is not silent!) by hand? not in my mobile they arn't!
The size of the track on that PCB was about 3 mm across This thing is sooo FAKE!
Posted Friday 30th January 2009 15:32 GMT
Em
Not likely voice recognition #
The device probably analyses the vibrations on the skull or jaw instead of actually analysing the human voice.
Jawbone uses this technique on their bluetooth headsets to filter background noise.
Posted Friday 30th January 2009 15:32 GMT
Lionel Baden
lolz #
No wonder they cant demo it because its a bloody mock up LOL
Posted Friday 30th January 2009 15:32 GMT
TeeCee
Re: 100% secure #
Maybe they've borrowed the widely-reported "super-encryption" from Obarmy's crackberry?
Rumour has it that the NSA have a roadmap to super-duper-encryption, mega-super-duper-encryption and mega-super-duper-encryption-with-knobs-on.
Posted Friday 30th January 2009 16:25 GMT
Robert E A Harvey
Green technology #
I'm surprised this wasn't sold as 'green' because the earpiece is obviously made of cardboard.
Paris - she understands a mockery. Perhaps her new best fiend will want one.
Posted Friday 30th January 2009 16:25 GMT
Andy ORourke
More concerned #
that the 1st guy from the company bears more than a passing resemblance to Anton Dubeck from that dancing show the wife watches, what does he know about website security?
On that subject if they have developed a 100% secure web site technology I would guess they could make more from that than any poxy phone?
Posted Friday 30th January 2009 16:25 GMT
Richard
Prior art? #
Er, Wildfire, anyone? Before it canned by Orange? Apparently there were plans to expand into non-voice areas, such as reading out email and text, but the plug got pulled. It shouldn't have been too difficult to get her to take dictation and send it out as a text or email.
Posted Friday 30th January 2009 18:16 GMT
Stoobin
Whats that smell? #
"If you loose this phone it is instantly useless to anyone else" -Thats right mate. It would probably be useless before I loose it. Because its not really a phone is it. Your just waving about a thin bit of plastic. I'd stick with your ejector seats. Good luck for the floatation.
Posted Friday 30th January 2009 18:17 GMT
2FishInATank
Did anyone else spot..... #
Did anyone else spot the bloke mentioning that the company was going to be floated on the stock exchange?
When I say the report last night my first thought was 'scam', and I've heard nothing to change my mind as yet!
Posted Sunday 1st February 2009 06:23 GMT
Pete "oranges" B.
It'll never catch on... #
...everyone will want a little triangular one that they can clip to their shirt's left pocket! What's with this in the ear nonsense?
This topic is closed for new posts.